In a two-voice canon, why must the composer think about counterpoint when writing the dux (leader) alone?
Think about your answer, then reveal below.
Model answer: Because the comes (follower) will reproduce the dux exactly, offset in time. Every measure of the dux will sound simultaneously with an earlier measure of the same melody. So when writing bar 3 of the dux, the composer must ensure it forms good counterpoint with bar 1 — the two bars will be heard together. The single line is always in counterpoint with itself.
This is the defining constraint of canon writing. Unlike free counterpoint, where two independent lines are composed against each other, a canon forces the composer to write one line that works as both melody and counterpoint simultaneously. The time interval and pitch interval of the imitation determine which measures will be in contact, so the composer must plan ahead for every upcoming vertical collision.