In y = sin(x − C), why does a positive value of C shift the graph to the right, even though subtracting seems like it should move the graph left?
Think about your answer, then reveal below.
Model answer: The phase shift moves the graph so that the pattern which began at x = 0 now begins at x = C. In y = sin(x), the wave starts its cycle where the argument equals zero — at x = 0. In y = sin(x − C), the argument equals zero when x = C, so the starting point has moved to x = C: a rightward shift. To get the same output that occurred at x = 0, you now need x = C — you must go further right to reach the same input value.
The confusion arises from thinking of the transformation as acting on the output (like a vertical shift), when it actually acts on the input. With input transformations, the effect is always reversed from intuition: subtracting C from the input means you need a larger x to reach the same argument value, so the graph shifts right. This is opposite to output transformations, where adding D shifts the graph up. The rule: input changes shift horizontally opposite to their sign; output changes shift vertically matching their sign.